The Logical Fallacy in Female Terrorists in Indonesia (Case Study: ISIS Period 2018-2023)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.70710/sitj.v1i2.12Keywords:
Counter-Terrorism, Female Terrorism, ISIS in Indonesia, Logical Fallacy, PatternAbstract
Terrorism represents a significant threat to both state and individual security. The effective combating of terrorism necessitates not only the implementation of repressive measures but also the fostering of societal resilience. The creation of societal resilience can be achieved by developing an intelligent society, thereby enabling it to combat the threat of radicalism and terrorism effectively. One way to foster societal resilience is to identify and address the logical fallacies of ISIS teachings. The authors selected the topic of female terrorists in Indonesia (ISIS case study 2018-2013 period) due to the increase in arrests of women related to terrorism following the Surabaya bombings in 2018. All of the women arrested are connected to ISIS. This paper employs the following theoretical frameworks: the informal logical fallacy theory (Van Vleet, Informal Logical Fallacies 2021), The Staircase to Terrorism (Mogadham, 2005), and Technic Analysis Counter Terrorism theory (Prunckun, 2010). The findings of the research indicated the presence of a logical fallacy among ISIS female terrorists. The logical fallacy observed in ISIS female terrorists in Indonesia can be attributed to the following factors: The indoctrination and education model employed by IS; the manipulation of religious teachings; the kinship system; the propagation of ideological narratives designed by IS; intense communication; the echo chamber and filter bubble; and women's psychological vulnerability all contribute to the phenomenon under study. The pattern of radicalization observed in ISIS female terrorists in Indonesia aligns with the theoretical framework of The Staircase to Terrorism (Fathali M. Moghadam). Counterterrorism measures must be implemented to address the logical fallacies observed in female terrorists. This necessitates a comprehensive approach encompassing prevention, preparation, response, and recovery.
Downloads
References
Adhi, Y T. 2022. “Kerancuan Berpikir dalam Tuturan Warganet di Favcebook.” Jurnal Bahasa, Sastra dan Pembelajarannya Vol.12, No.2 Oktober.
Ali, Farhana. 2006. “Rocking the Cradle to Rocking the World: The Role of Muslim Female Fighters.” Journal of International Women Studies, Vol.8, Issue 1.
Badri, Ahmad Ibrahim, wawancara oleh A N Damayanti. 2024. Dr.,S. Fil, M. Hum. (15 Februari).
Barret, Richard. 2017. Beyond the Caliphate: Foreign Fighters and the Threat of Returnees. The Soufan Center and The Global Strategy Network.
Berko, Anat, Edna Erez, and Julie L Globokar. 2010. "Gender, Crime and Terrorism: The Case of Arab/Palestinian Women in Israel." The British Journal of Criminology, Vol.50, Issue 4 670-689.
Christensen, Tom, Per Lægreidb, dan Lise H. Rykkja. 2019. “How to Balance Individual Rights and Societal Security? The View of Civil Servants.” Studies in Conflict & Terrorism (Routledge, Taylor and Francis Online) (Studies in Conflict and Terrorism): 1-17.
Copi, Irving M, Carl Cohen, and Victor Radyh. 2019. "Fallacies." In Introduction to Logic, by Irving M Copi, Carl Cohen and Victor Radyh, 50. Routledge.
Damarjati, Danu. 2018. Terorisme Terlaknat 2018 : Bom Sekeluarga Mengguncang Surabaya. Jakarta: Detiknews.
Damyati, Akhmad Rofii. 2020. “"Pancasilais" vs "Radikalis": Menguak Logical Fallacies yang Terabaikan.” The First International Conference on Islamic Thought (ICIT). Pamekasan: IAI Al Khairat. 1013-1025.
Eggert, Jennifer Philippa . 2018. “Female Fighters and Militants During the Lebanese Civil War: Individual Profiles, Pathways, and Motivations.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism 1-29.
Fithriyyah, Mustiqowati Ummul , Muhammad Saiful Umam, Atika Windi Astuti, dan Muammar Alkhadafi. 2021. “Redefinition of Religious Nation-state; Tracing Textual Doctrine and its Impact on Religious Violence in Indonesia.” ADDIN, Media Dialektika Ilmu Islam 23-40.
Galehan, Jordan. 2019. “Instruments of violence: Female suicide bombers of Boko Haram.” International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice, vol.58 113-123.
Ghazali, Effendi, wawancara oleh A N Damayanti. 2024. Prof. Dr., M.Si., MPS., Ph.D. (16 Februari).
Hikam, Muhammad A.S, wawancara oleh A N Damayanti. 2024. Prof. Dr., , M.A., A.P.U (16 Januari).
IPAC. 2020. “Perempuan Ekstremis di Balik Jeruji Besi Indonesia.”
Jones, David A., dan Lorne L Dawson. 2021. “Re-examining the explanations of convert radicalization in Salafi-Jihadist terrorism with evidence from Canada.” Behavioral Science of Terrorism and Political Aggrtion 246-273.
Khoei, Mahdieh Aghazadeh. 2015. “Iran’s Security and the Islamic State (IS) Through the Lenses of the Copenhagen School.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism 1035-1041.
Khoiri, N E, dan U Widiawati. 2017. “Logical Fallacies in Indonesian EFL Learners' Argumentative Writing : Students'Perspektives.” Dinamika Ilmu Vol.17 No.1.
Lasmawati, Arijani, wawancara oleh A N Damayanti. 2023. Dr., S.Psi., M.Psi (4 Oktober).
Malin, Wimelius Eklund, Malin Eriksson, John Kinsman, Veronica Strandh, dan Mehdi Ghazinour. 2023. “What is Local Resilience Against Radicalization and How can it be Promoted? A Multidisciplinary Literature Review.” Studies In conflict & terrorism (Taylor & Francis Group, LLC) (Studies in): 1108-1125.
Mariana. 2021. Penembakan Mabes Polri :'Terduga teroris berideologi ISIS', polisi ungkap identitas berusia 25 tahun pelaku serangan . Jakarta: BBC News Indonesia.
McBridge, Dawn M, and J Cooper Cutting. 2018. Cognitive Psychology: Theory, Process, and Methodology. New York: SAGE Publication.
Mogadham, Fathali M. 2005. “The Staircase to Terrorism, A Psychological Exploration.” (Geogetown University) 60, No. 2, 161–169 (American Psychologist).
Mondza, Lil Askar. 2019. Lewat Pengeras Suara Masjid, Ulama Bujuk Teroris Menyerah. Medan: Tempo.co.
Nizwana, Y. 2021. “Logical Fallacy dan Pertentangan Moral dalam Pembebasan Narapidana di Era Pandemi Covid 19.” Riau Journal Law.
Prasetya, Ardi Putra, wawancara oleh A N Damayanti. 2024. Dr.S.Sos., M.Krim (18 Januari).
Prunckun, Hank. 2010. Handbook of Scientific Methods of Inquiry for Intelligence Analysis . United States: The Scarecrown Press, Inc.
Raghavan, S V, dan V Balasubramanian. 2014. “Evolving role of women in terror groups: Progression or regression?” Journal of International Women Studies, Vol. 15, Issue 2 197-211.
Rahmanto, Didik Novi, Adrianus Eliasta Meliala, and Fendinand T Andi Lolo. 2020. "Ideology deconstruction of Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) returnees in Indonesia." Indonesian Journal of Islam and Muslim Societies 381-408.
Rassat, Fianda Sofjan. 2022. Polisi sebut motif perempuan penerobos istana ingin temui presiden. Jakarta: antaranews.com .
Rohmadi, Y, and W Irmawati. 2020. Dasar-dasar Logika. Surakarta: EFUDEPRESS, Fakultas Ushluhuddin dan Dakwah IAIN Surakarta.
Sahrasad, Herdi, and Al Chaidar. 2017. "ISIS,Indonesian Muslims and Global Terrorism, A Reflection." JICSA Volume 06 - Number 01, June 50-91.
Shofiyullah, H, Rizal Mumazziq J, Fathurrahman Karyadi, Lumatul Fitria, dan M Ali Maksum. 2011. Revitalisasi Humanisme Religius dan Kebangsaan KH. A. Wahid Hasyim. Jombang: Pustaka Tebuireng.
Sodik, MD, wawancara oleh A N Damayanti. 2024. Kombes Pol (19 Januari).
Spencer, Amanda N. 2016. “The Hidden Face of Terrorism: An Analysis of the Women in Islamic State.” Journal of Strategic Security, Vol. 9, No. 3, Special Issue: Emerging Threats 74-90.
Sukabdi, Zora Arfina, wawancara oleh A N Damayanti. 2024. Dr.,S.Psi., M. Psi (16 Januari).
Sunny, Amril Ghaffar, wawancara oleh A N Damayanti. 2024. Prof.Dr.Ph.D,Drs,MS.SE.,MM. (Januari).
Susanti, Eni, Andi Ismira, and Sadriani. 2023. "Analisis Propaganda Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) di Indonesia Melalui Jalur Media Sosial." Hasanuddin Journal of International Affairs, Volume 3, No 2, August 2 123-138.
Van Vleet, Jacob E . 2021. Informal Logical Fallacies. London: Rowman & Littlefield Publishing Group, Inc.
Van Vleet, Jacob E. 2021. Informal Logical Fallacy : a Brief Guide. Rowman & Littlefield.
Vrbová, Lucie , Kateřina Jiřinová,, Hana Lorencová, dan Karel Helman. 2021. “Do informal reasoning fallacies really shape decisions? Experimental evidence.” Sage Journal Vol.22, Issue 4.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Security Intelligence Terrorism Journal (SITJ)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
